Law firms hold exactly what attackers are looking for: privileged communications, financial records, personal information and, in many practices, wire instructions for settlements and real estate closings. That makes small and mid-sized firms a regular target.
Arizona's ethics rules don't tell you which software to buy. They set a standard, reasonable efforts, and leave it to each firm to meet it. Here's what the rules say and what meeting them looks like in practice.
What the rules say
ER 1.6(e): reasonable efforts to protect client information. Arizona's confidentiality rule says: "A lawyer shall make reasonable efforts to prevent the inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure of, or unauthorized access to, information relating to the representation of a client."
The key word is reasonable. The rule doesn't require perfect security, and a breach alone doesn't mean a lawyer violated it. The question is whether the firm's safeguards were sensible for the information it holds.
ER 1.1: competence includes technology. Arizona's comment to the competence rule says lawyers should keep up with changes in the law and its practice, "including the benefits and risks associated with relevant technology." You don't have to become an IT expert, but you're expected to understand the risks of the tools you use, or work with someone who does.
ER 5.3: you're responsible for the people who help you. Lawyers who supervise nonlawyers, inside or outside the firm, have to make reasonable efforts to make sure their conduct fits the lawyer's own obligations, including confidentiality. Staff count, and so do outside providers who handle client information, like your IT company and your software vendors.
ER 1.4: keeping clients informed. The duty to communicate with clients comes into play after a breach, when clients may need to know what happened to their information.
What the ethics opinions add
Arizona Ethics Opinion 05-04 (2005). Storing client information on computers is fine, as long as the lawyer takes competent and reasonable steps to protect it. The opinion mentions firewalls, security software, passwords, encryption and routine backups. If a lawyer can't reasonably develop that competence, the opinion says to retain an expert who has it.
Arizona Ethics Opinion 09-04 (2009). Storing client files online is permitted with reasonable security precautions. Lawyers should develop or consult someone with competence in online security, and periodically review their security measures as technology changes.
ABA Formal Opinion 477R (2017). Lawyers may use email and other common tools, but must weigh the sensitivity of the information, the likelihood of disclosure, and the cost and difficulty of extra safeguards. Highly sensitive matters may call for stronger protection, like encryption.
ABA Formal Opinion 483 (2018). After a breach, lawyers should act to stop it, restore their systems, figure out what happened, and notify current clients when material client information was involved or likely involved. The opinion also notes a duty to monitor for breaches in the first place.
ABA Formal Opinion 512 (2024). Before entering client information into a generative AI tool, lawyers need to understand how the tool uses and stores that information. If the tool learns from what you enter, the opinion says you generally need the client's informed consent first, and boilerplate in an engagement letter isn't enough.
ABA opinions aren't binding in Arizona, but they're widely used as a guide to what "reasonable" means.
What reasonable looks like in a small firm
There's no official checklist. For most small and mid-sized firms, these safeguards cover the basics the rules and opinions describe:
- Multi-factor authentication on email, practice management, document storage, banking and remote access
- Encrypted laptops and phones, with the ability to wipe a lost device
- Automatic updates and monitored protection against viruses and ransomware
- Email filtering and a callback rule. Any change to wire or payment instructions gets confirmed by phone, using a number you already have on file. Here's how to spot a fake invoice or payment email.
- A secure way to share sensitive documents, like a client portal or encrypted email, instead of ordinary attachments
- Backups that include Microsoft 365, with restores tested regularly
- Access limited to what each person needs, and prompt removal of access when someone leaves
- Vendor due diligence. Before you put client files in a cloud service, ask how it secures them, who can access them and how you get your data back if you leave.
- Staff training, because most attacks start with an email
- A written incident response plan that covers your IT provider, your insurance carrier, client notification and any legal notice requirements
- A written policy on AI tools, covering what client information can and can't go into them
Don't forget Arizona's breach law
Ethics rules aren't the only obligation. Arizona's data breach notification law, A.R.S. 18-552, applies to law firms that keep personal information electronically. It generally requires notifying affected people within 45 days. When more than 1,000 people are involved, you also notify the three credit bureaus, the attorney general and the Arizona Department of Homeland Security. Corporate clients may also have security requirements in their outside counsel guidelines, so check those agreements too.
How we help
We support law firms across the Phoenix area with the safeguards above: multi-factor authentication, encrypted devices, 24/7 security monitoring, secure file sharing and staff training. We also help firms answer the security questionnaires that corporate clients and insurers send.
This article is general information, not legal or ethics advice. For questions about your own obligations, Arizona lawyers can call the State Bar's ethics hotline.